Two grooms, each in the other's wedding party, married on August 5 and 7. About nineteen guys flying in from Detroit, Dallas and Atlanta. Good golf is the one thing that is not negotiable.
Every number on this site is a 2026 published rate with a source behind it. We scored ten cities on the same seven things, then built dials so the group can see what moves when the priorities change. The chips below are Edmund's answers; Dapo's are still to come.


Edmund answered the questionnaire on October 8 and Dapo agreed, so it is the baseline: May, four to five nights, up to $2,000 a head, a rental house if the numbers allow, some guys in their own rooms, mild weather, good golf non negotiable. Only two cities can put nineteen guys under one roof legally and inside the budget, and both have golf a few minutes away.

Cheapest flights of the ten, 10 bedroom pool homes at $74 to $93 per guy per night, and golf everywhere from $50 to $136. It is a golf plus house party trip, not a night out trip, and summer afternoons bring lightning most days.

Lake Travis party barges, Sixth and Rainey, Hill Country barbecue, and the Dallas guys can drive. Omni Barton Creek is $450 plus a night with guests only golf, Detroit has a single Delta nonstop, and everything is 20 to 60 minutes apart.

Nonstops from all three cities, summer golf at $69 to $130, and a casino, pool and sportsbook under every hotel so twenty guys never need a car or a plan to stay together.
Vegas, Nashville, New Orleans, Tampa and Myrtle Beach all cap or ban big rental houses for groups, and Scottsdale's estates stop at 16 with a party ordinance. Orlando's ChampionsGate homes sleep 22 to 30 with enough bedrooms for the guys who need their own, and Austin's Lake Travis houses sleep 20 with a dock. In a house, an own room is just claiming a bedroom; at a hotel it is $75 to $190 a night extra.
Compare Orlando and Austin→Mild weather: neither Orlando (86 in May) nor Austin (84) is mild, and neither is Vegas (89). Only San Diego, Myrtle Beach and Nashville in May, and Tahoe in June, are. San Diego comes back into range at $2,000 but the big houses have week long minimums. The calendar still matters more than the city: Wednesday May 12 to Sunday May 16 or May 19 to 23 is before Memorial Day, before the Florida storm season and before the Texas heat.
See the date windows→Treat these as the ground rules for the vote. The original research ran on a tighter $1,500 brief with a resort first; that version is still in the full report and as the Original brief preset on the priorities page.
Weddings are August 5 and 7. Trip in May or June, four nights, five if the PTO allows. Avoid Memorial Day (May 31), Father's Day (June 20), CMA Fest in Nashville (June 9 to 14) and July entirely.
Up to $2,000 a head all in. Some guys need their own room. Whether the group covers the grooms is open; Edmund said it would be nice but funds may not be easy for everyone, so the roster asks each guy his real ceiling.
A rental house to keep everyone together. Mild weather preferred. Good golf is the one non negotiable. Edmund's own words on location: anywhere, as long as it is not ghetto.
Tap any city for its own page: where to stay, courses, excursions, the dinner, sample math and risks.

Seven dials and a live ranking. See what happens when nightlife matters more than weather, or when the budget moves.

Round trip fares from DTW, DFW and ATL to every city, plus the four windows to book and the four to avoid.

How rooms, tee times and the money work when twenty guys each book their own room and one person runs the pool.